NIE vs TIE vs DNI: The Spanish ID card explainer for remote workers

Spain
Written By Maya Middlemiss

If you've spent any time navigating Spanish bureaucracy as a foreigner, you've probably encountered a confusing soup of acronyms: NIE, TIE, DNI, NIF. They sound similar, they're all related to identity, and getting them mixed up can send you to entirely the wrong government office. Let's untangle this once and for all!

As someone who has lived through the evolution of Spain's identity document system – and watched it become simultaneously more digital and more confusing – I can tell you that understanding these distinctions isn't just bureaucratic trivia. It's the foundation for everything else: opening a bank account, signing a rental contract, filing taxes, and accessing public services.

Here's what each document actually is, who needs which one, and what's changing as Spain – somewhat unevenly – moves into the digital age.

The basics: what each document actually is

Oh yes, there’s always more than one you need to know about and deal with – get used to that, in Spain.

DNI – Documento Nacional de Identidad

The DNI is Spain's national ID card, and it's exclusively for Spanish citizens. If you're not Spanish, you will never have a DNI – and that single fact creates a significant divide in how you interact with Spanish systems.

The DNI is a credit-card-sized document containing the holder's photo, signature, fingerprints, and a unique identification number. Since 2006, it has included an electronic chip (the DNI electrónico or DNIe) that enables digital signatures and secure online authentication.

For Spanish citizens, the DNI is mandatory from age 14 and serves as both an identity document and a travel document within the EU and Schengen area. It's the key that unlocks Spain's increasingly digital public services – and as we'll see, that's where things get complicated for the rest of us.

NIE – Número de Identidad de Extranjero

The NIE is simply a number – a tax identification number assigned to foreigners who have economic, professional, or social interests in Spain. That's it. It's not a card, not a residence permit, not proof of anything except that the Spanish tax system knows you exist.

The NIE format is distinctive: a letter (X, Y, or Z), followed by seven digits, followed by another letter. For example: X1234567A. Once assigned, your NIE never changes – it follows you through all your dealings with Spanish authorities, from buying property to filing tax returns. Here's where confusion often starts: you can get an NIE without living in Spain, and having an NIE doesn't give you the right to live or work here. A British person buying a holiday home needs an NIE. A German freelancer spending three months in Valencia needs an NIE. Neither necessarily has residence rights.

The NIE is available to both EU and non-EU citizens, and the number itself never expires. However, the paper document you receive (sometimes called the "white NIE" or certificado de asignación de NIE) is simply proof that the number exists – it's not an identity document.

However it is an identity number, and will frequently be cited in place of the NIF when a foreigner is involved. Collecting a parcel. signing a contract, making a denuncia or a medical appointment? Get used to stating your NIE, in Spanish, as it will follow you wherever you go! It never changes or expires, and as such when you need to offer primary ID for something it’s often better to use this than anything else (such as a British passport which will have a different unique number when you renew it in 10 years time – which has caused me pain the past!

TIE – Tarjeta de Identidad de Extranjero

The TIE is a physical residence card issued to non-EU nationals who have obtained legal residency in Spain. It's a proper biometric ID card – plastic, with your photo, fingerprints, and a chip – that serves as proof of your right to be here.

If you're from outside the EU and you're living in Spain legally (on a work visa, student visa, digital nomad visa, non-lucrative residence, or any other long-term permission), you need a TIE. The card displays your NIE number, your name, nationality, the type of residence permit you hold, and its validity dates.

Unlike the NIE number itself, the TIE expires – typically aligned with your underlying visa or residence permission. Renewing it is a regular feature of expat life for non-EU nationals in Spain. However the status it grants may well last longer than the physical card – for example those issued to long-term residents from the UK who were present in Spain prior to the withdrawal agreement. In theory, it should be straightforward to replace the card only, when it reaches its expiry date.

And for EU citizens? The green NIE

EU, EEA, and Swiss nationals occupy a middle ground. You don't get a TIE (that's for non-EU nationals only), but you're entitled to more than just a bare NIE number.

If you're an EU citizen planning to stay in Spain for more than three months, you should register for the Certificado de Registro de Ciudadano de la Unión – commonly known as the "green NIE" because of the colour of the paper it's printed on. This confirms your right of residence under EU free movement rules.

The green NIE is mandatory if you're staying longer than 90 days, and it's required for most practical purposes: employment contracts, bank accounts, accessing healthcare, and registering as autónomo. The process involves proving you have health coverage and sufficient financial means – though requirements vary somewhat by province.

One quirk: the green NIE doesn't include a photo, which means it's only valid when presented alongside your passport or national ID card from your home country. It's a certificate, not a standalone ID document.

What each document unlocks:

DocumentWho gets itWhat it provesWhat it unlocks
DNISpanish citizens onlySpanish nationality & identityFull digital services, EU travel, voting
NIE (number)Any foreigner with interests in SpainTax ID existsBank accounts, property, tax filing
Green NIEEU/EEA/Swiss residentsEU residence rights registeredEmployment, healthcare, autónomo
TIENon-EU with residence permitsLegal residence status & typeAll above + photo ID document

The digital divide nobody talks about

Here's where the situation gets frustrating for anyone who isn't a Spanish citizen.

In April 2025, Spain launched MiDNI – a mobile app that lets Spanish citizens carry a digital version of their DNI on their smartphones. The app generates secure QR codes validated against police databases in real time, with three levels of information depending on what's needed: age verification only, basic identity, or full document details.

It's genuinely impressive technology. Spanish citizens can now prove their identity, sign documents electronically, and access government services – all from their phones, with biometric authentication and real-time security validation. Starting in April 2026, they'll be able to demand that public and private entities accept the digital DNI as valid identification.

But here's the catch: MiDNI is not available to foreign residents.

If you're a non-EU national with a TIE, or an EU citizen with a green NIE, you cannot use MiDNI. The app is tied specifically to the DNI system – which, remember, is only for Spanish nationals.

This creates a growing digital divide. Spanish citizens are moving toward a world where identity verification is instant and mobile. Foreign residents – including those who've lived here for decades, pay taxes, and are fully integrated into Spanish society – are stuck with paper documents, in-person appointments, and systems designed for a pre-digital era.

Digital certificates and Cl@ve: the workarounds

Spain does offer digital access tools for foreigners – they're just more cumbersome than what citizens enjoy.

The FNMT digital certificate

The Fábrica Nacional de Moneda y Timbre (FNMT) issues digital certificates that anyone with an NIE can obtain. These certificates enable electronic signatures and access to government services – they're essentially the workhorse of Spanish digital bureaucracy for foreigners.

The catch? The process is notoriously finicky. You must request the certificate online, verify your identity in person at an approved office, then download the certificate – all on the same computer, same browser, same user account. Change any element of that chain, and you start over. The certificates are valid for four years before you need to repeat the process, and attend another in person appointment.

Cl@ve

Cl@ve is the Spanish government's unified authentication system, available to anyone with an NIE or DNI. It comes in two flavours: Cl@ve PIN (temporary codes for one-time access) and Cl@ve Permanente (a username/password system for ongoing use).

For most expat needs – filing tax returns, checking Social Security status, booking immigration appointments – Cl@ve works. But it's not a substitute for full digital identity. High-security transactions still require either a digital certificate or in-person verification.

I'll be writing a detailed guide to getting set up with Cl@ve and digital certificates soon – the process deserves its own article.

What's coming: EU Digital Identity Wallet

There's potentially good news on the horizon. Under the eIDAS 2.0 regulation, all EU member states must provide at least one European Digital Identity Wallet (EUDI Wallet) to citizens and residents by the end of 2026, under eIDAS 2.0 implementation deadlines.

The key word there is "residents." If implemented as the regulation intends, the EUDIW should be available not just to Spanish nationals, but to anyone legally residing in Spain – including non-EU nationals with valid residence permits.

The wallet will enable:

  • Secure identity verification across all EU countries

  • Qualified electronic signatures with the same legal weight as handwritten ones

  • Storage of official documents and credentials

  • Cross-border authentication for public and private services

For foreign residents in Spain, this could be transformative. Instead of the current patchwork of paper documents, digital certificates, and inconsistent requirements, there would be a single, standardised system that works across borders.

Spain has already been piloting elements of this with the Cartera Digital Beta, and the MiDNI app could potentially evolve to incorporate EUDIW functionality. But whether foreign residents will truly get equal access remains to be seen – the implementation details matter enormously.

Cross-border recognition: eIDAS and what it means for you

Even before the wallet arrives, EU regulations on electronic identification already provide some protections. Under eIDAS, qualified electronic signatures from any EU member state must be recognised across all member states.

This means if you have a qualified digital signature from your home country – whether that's a Belgian itsme®, an Estonian e-Residency digital ID, or a German eID – Spanish authorities are legally required to accept it with the same validity as a signature from the Spanish FNMT system.

In practice, implementation is uneven. Some Spanish government portals accept foreign EU digital signatures smoothly; others have technical limitations that make it difficult. But the legal framework exists, and it's worth knowing your rights if you're told a foreign digital ID "doesn't work" in Spain.

Practical advice: which documents do you actually need?

If you're an EU citizen planning to stay more than 90 days:

  • Get your green NIE as soon as possible – it's required within three months of arrival

  • Register for Cl@ve to access digital services

  • Consider getting an FNMT digital certificate for anything more than basic tasks

If you're a non-EU citizen with a residence visa:

  • You'll receive a TIE as part of your residence process – this is your primary ID in Spain

  • Your TIE includes your NIE number, so you don't need a separate NIE document

  • Get Cl@ve and an FNMT certificate set up early – you'll need them constantly

If you're visiting or have non-resident interests in Spain:

  • A basic NIE (just the number) is sufficient for property purchases, tax matters, or opening certain bank accounts

  • You can apply at Spanish consulates abroad or at foreigner's offices in Spain

The bottom line

Spain's identity document system reflects decades of accumulated bureaucracy, with different documents created at different times for different purposes. For foreign residents, the result is a parallel system that's functional but increasingly dated compared to what Spanish citizens enjoy.

The coming EU Digital Identity Wallet offers hope for simplification and equal access – but we're not there yet. In the meantime, understanding the difference between NIE, TIE, and DNI isn't just administrative knowledge. It's survival skills for anyone building a life in Spain.

Sources

Maya Middlemiss
Next

The OECD finally acknowledges remote work exists. Here's what that means for you.